Auditors and the Principal-Principal Agency Conflict in Family Controlled Firms

Family firms are widespread among public companies in France. In a recent paper, Ben Ali, Boubaker & Magnan, provide evidence that the presence of multiple large shareholders (MLS) beyond the largest controlling shareholder (LCS) mitigates the agency conflicts between large and minority shareholders, hence reducing the level of audit fees paid by family-controlled firms.

Using a sample of listed family-controlled firms in France over 2003–2013, their findings support the idea that auditors view MLS as performing a monitoring role over the controlling family, mitigating the potential for the extraction of private benefits by the LCS. More specifically, it appears that auditors expect MLS to mitigate the likelihood that LCS diverts corporate resources to the detriment of non-controlling shareholders.

By performing such a monitoring role, MLS reduce auditors’ risk exposure and, ultimately, lead them to reduce their efforts and fees. Auditors’ reactions to the presence of MLS are hence consistent with ISA 315 which requires auditors to assess the risks of financial misreporting through a better understanding of the entity being audited, especially in terms of its ownership and governance processes. 

The research of Chiraz Ben Ali, Sabri Boubaker & Michel Magnan.

Author(s)

One of the main challenges for small and medium enterprises (SMEs) is how to leverage their R&D activities in the international markets but current literature offers mixed evidence and inconclusive models in this regard.  The relationships among SMEs’ international R&D activities, dynamic capabilities and performance are still not well understood, despite their importance for the managerial practices in […]

Within the context of the internationalization of organizations and, in particular, growing numbers of staff members from different cultures, the number of studies on the management of cultural differences has increased considerably. However, as several authors have observed, studies on cultural differences and the concept of cultural identity remain limited, in large part due to […]

When it comes to work engagement (one’s vigor, dedication, and absorption directed to work tasks), some job resources are more important for some, but not for others – and it is largely dependent on your office location. Halinski and Harrison (2020) recently published an article in the International Journal of Public Sector Management, exploring this hypothesis with public service employees in […]